When MG leaves me speaking in cursive, I focus on listening instead

Slurring makes me 'slow to speak.' Now I'm trying to be 'swift to hear.'

Written by Mark Harrington |

main banner for Mark Harrington's

As a teacher, I had a handful of stories I told so often that my students could mouth the words as I spoke. One of them was about Demosthenes.

As a boy in ancient Athens, Demosthenes could hardly get a sentence out. According to Plutarch, his speech was indistinct and his breath was short, and his playmates saddled him with an unflattering nickname. So, he went to work. He filled his mouth with pebbles and practiced until the words came out clear. He ran uphill reciting verses. He went down to the shore and shouted over the waves, so that no noisy crowd in the assembly could ever drown him out. He became the greatest orator Greece ever produced.

I loved telling that story to sophomores who swore they could never give a two-minute presentation. Then myasthenia gravis (MG) came along and flipped it on me. Here’s the irony: Demosthenes put the pebbles in his mouth on purpose. MG puts them in mine without asking.

Recommended Reading
Banner image for

Trouble Eating and Speaking: Center Stage of My Bulbar Issues

Many days, usually late in the afternoon, my words start to thicken. My tongue gets lazy, my voice drifts up into my nose, and I sound like I’m talking through a wet towel. Doctors call it dysarthria, or slow and slurred speech, and it’s more common than most people realize. It’s estimated to affect about 60% of people with MG as the disease progresses.

For 30 years, my voice was my livelihood. A teacher in an inner-city classroom, I didn’t get a podium or a microphone. I had my voice, and it had to carry over a room full of teenagers who had other plans for the period. I was the Demosthenes of my classroom, shouting over the waves every single day.

Now, the harder I push my voice, the faster it gives out. That’s the cruel arithmetic of MG. The muscles weaken with use. Demosthenes got stronger by straining. If I tried his method, I’d be speaking gibberish by suppertime.

I’ve had to learn a lesson that Demosthenes never taught, because he never needed it. Sometimes the strongest thing a man can say is nothing at all.

Learning to embrace the quiet

Scottish writer Thomas Carlyle put it this way in “Sartor Resartus”: “Speech is of Time, Silence is of Eternity.” I used to think that was the kind of line a Victorian wrote when he wanted his dinner guests to stop talking. Now I think he was onto something.

Often when my voice gives out, I listen better. I hear what’s underneath the words. At a family dinner, I notice who hasn’t spoken yet, and who has something on their mind. I used to be the one filling every quiet moment with a story about the Battle of Bunker Hill. These days, I let the quiet do some of the work.

The Apostle James offers advice I read differently now than I did as a young man: “Let every man be swift to hear, slow to speak, slow to wrath.” MG has made me slow to speak whether I like it or not. I’m trying to make sure the “swift to hear” part keeps pace.

Eloquent silence sounds poetic, but on the hard days it takes some planning. I schedule important conversations for the morning, when my voice is freshest. I keep a notepad nearby, and I’m not too proud to use it. A crucial tactic is texting instead of calling once the afternoon thickening sets in. I’ve told the people closest to me what my slurred speech means, so they don’t mistake it for something else. I let a smile or a nod say what my mouth can’t.

Researchers have found that people with MG may not fully realize how much their speech has changed, and they recommend speech therapy evaluations even when patients don’t complain. If your voice has been slipping, it’s worth asking your neurologist about a referral.

Demosthenes shouted over the sea so that no one could drown him out. I’ve made a different peace with the waves. Some days, I let them roar, and I simply sit on the shore and listen.

I still tell the story of the pebbles — I’ve just given it a new ending. The man who conquered his voice is a fine example. But so is the man who loses his voice for an afternoon and discovers he still has plenty to say.

Finally — and feel free to use this — when my voice gets slurred, I tell people that I’m not slurring; I’m speaking in cursive.


Note: Myasthenia Gravis News is strictly a news and information website about the disease. It does not provide medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment. This content is not intended to be a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment. Always seek the advice of your physician or other qualified health provider with any questions you may have regarding a medical condition. Never disregard professional medical advice or delay in seeking it because of something you have read on this website. The opinions expressed in this column are not those of Myasthenia Gravis News or its parent company, Bionews, and are intended to spark discussion about issues pertaining to myasthenia gravis.

Leave a comment

Fill in the required fields to post. Your email address will not be published.

Comments are moderated. Once approved, your comment and username will be publicly visible. Please avoid sharing personal health information or other sensitive details.